"Niyat (नियत)"
Watched Hindi movie "Niyat (नियत)".
This movie is directed by Anu Menon. Written by Anu Menon and others. Produced by Vikram Malhotra. Music by Mickey McCleary. Cinematography by Andreas Neo. This movie features Vidya Balan, Ram Kapoor, Niki Aneja, Naaraj Kaabi, Rahul Bose, Prajakta Koli, Amrita Puri, Shahana Goswami, Dipannita Sharma, Danesh Razvi, Ishita Mehra and guest appearance of Shefali Shah. This movie was released in 2023 and runs for about 2 hour 10 min. I watched the movie on Amazon Prime on 4th Sep 2023 with Aditi.
Ram Kapoor is a big businessman absconding from India, accused of borrowing 20,000 crores from banks, allegedly having a massive loss and not having paid employees for two years. He invites people close to him on a remote island in Scotland for his birthday. An unexpected guest in the form of Vidya, a CBI officer, arrives. She’s not uninvited. Someone dies, another death ….. Ram.
It’s an interesting collection of characters. Ram’s brother in law (Rahul), his step son and sons girlfriend, Ram’s healer, Ram’s best friend (Neeraj), his wife (Deepannita) and son, Ram’s woman Friday (Amrita), the event manager (Danesh), Ram’s girlfriend (Shahana) and his distant student relative. All of them are dependent on Ram for money. All of them have some kind of history with him. They all love him and have a reason to hate him. Do they have a reason strong enough to either make him commit suicide or kill him?
It’s a murder mystery. A whodunit! With an isolated island, the suspects are limited in number. The setting is very similar to Agatha Christie novels. Large house, isolated place, rich man, lot of dependents, everyone has a motive, detective in the mix, revelation at the end. It also has many similarities with English movie Knives out, but it’s not a remake.
When you make a murder mystery, there are few things that need to be kept in mind. You should hide the perpetrator very well. The clues should be placed innocuously, so that when revelation happens audience should blame themselves for not realizing it earlier. The story should be watertight with no holes in it for the ship to sail and stay afloat. If there are holes the ship will take water and may even sink.
This is where the movie falters. There are too many holes in the story and they aren’t plugged. There are a lot of unanswered questions. Why send the staff away? Why bank on briefcase when the risk could be avoided? What was the mode of gate away from island? The scissors were stolen after the use… continuity issue. Why wait 18 years for DNA test? Why kill Kay?
The acting of most of the characters is good. Ram portrays larger than life character. Rahul plays out of character. Neeraj is good. Niki makes a comeback of sorts but looks swollen. Now let’s talk about Vidya. She plays a CBI officer. But despite having a sharp mind she is shown confused most of the time. She does all the right things but doesn’t appear driven. Doesn’t appear woman on mission. I wonder why director chose to portray her like this?
Nevertheless the overall effect of the movie is not bad. You don’t get bored. Although you don’t get a satisfaction of watching a good movie, you also don’t feel it was a waste of time.
Positives: Overall effect.
Negatives: As listed above.
Ok to watch once.